India v australia first test mark taylor pat cummins hamstrung by selection comments 20230213 p5j3jl.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Watch Live
Premier League on StanrightArrow
This was published 3 years ago

EXCLUSIVE: Selectors under fire over 'mixed messages' following first Test debacle

Damien McCartney
Damien McCartney

Powered by

Former Test captain Mark Taylor believes Pat Cummins was hamstrung by selection in India and claims selectors sent "mixed messages" about the direction of the spin line-up.

Taylor said an Aussie attack consisting of two right-arm quicks and two right-arm spinners meant Cummins, captaining his side in India for the first time, had little variation at his disposal.

"I don't think he could have done too much more as a captain - he's a bit limited by the side they chose," he told Wide World of Sports. 

Advertisement

AS IT HAPPENED: India v Australia first Test

READ MORE: Aussies 'embarrassed' in record defeat in India

READ MORE: Cobbo hat-trick propels Indigenous to victory

"When you've got two right-arm quicks and two right-arm off-spinners as your four-man attack, it's very difficult to do much more with that.

"I think that's something they're going to have to look at for the next Test match.

"It's not going to be easy for him full stop because the pitches aren't going to suit his (Cummins') bowling."

Australia's captain Pat Cummins, left, adjusts fielding as Todd Murphy watches during the third day of the first cricket test match between India and Australia in Nagpur, India, Saturday, Feb. 11, 2023. (AP Photo/Rafiq Maqbool)

Pat Cummins (left) speaks with debutant Todd Murphy. AP

The bowling attack consisted of off-spinners Nathan Lyon and debutant Todd Murphy, who took 1-126 and 7-124 respectively, as well as pacemen Cummins (2-78) and Scott Boland (0-34).

Advertisement

Cummins didn't have the handy medium pace of Cameron Green at his disposal because of the youngster's broken finger.

Taylor is confused about the spinning pecking order.

"They picked Mitch Swepson for the Pakistan tour last year, then didn't pick him in Sydney," Taylor said.

"The only reason I can think they went for (Ashton) Agar in Sydney was as a dress rehearsal for this Test match just gone, and they didn't pick him.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"So they've sent out mixed messages, and now Agar will have to be considered.

Taylor said the dismissal of KS Bharat to have the Indians 7-240 late on day two would have been the perfect moment to bowl Marnus Labuschagne and Steve Smith.

"They were still in the game at that stage … they needed to bowl India out for probably 270 or less to really have a chance to turn the Test match around."

'The final frontier': How young gun's debut, captain's injury sparked Australia's iconic 2004 series win in India

It was during a series against India that he formed a strong bond with Michael Clarke, offering-up his place in the Test team after Clarke belted 151 runs on debut.

Two decades since 'the final frontier' was conquered: How young gun's debut sparked Australia's iconic 2004 win in India

Most viewed in Cricket

More to explore