NRL top 50: Grand finalists lock out five of the top six spots as Nathan Cleary reigns supreme again
As the NRL's official broadcaster, Nine takes the world's elite rugby league competition very seriously, so when we decided to do a top 50 players list we wanted to make sure we were doing it right.
That's why we enlisted a panel of 12 judges, including several of the best players of all-time as well as Nine's top rugby league journalists who watch and cover the game for a living.
The panel we put together consists of: Andrew Johns, Darren Lockyer, Brad Fittler, Allana Ferguson, Marlee Silva, Roy Masters, Michael Chammas, Robert Dillon, Billie Eder, Dan Walsh, Adrian Proszenko and Christian Nicolussi.
READ MORE: Matildas coach gives update on Kerr's future captaincy
READ MORE: Volk's shock next fight after UFC champ vacates title
READ MORE: Raducanu thanks fans for support after incident with 'fixated' man
Click on this link to find out how the judges chose the top 50 NRL players for 2025 and click this link to revisit the 10 players who landed from 20-11.
The countdown concludes with the judges' top 10 players in the competition.
Read on below to find out who we've deemed to be the elite of the elite.
- Graphics by Polly Hanning
Getty
10. STEPHEN CRICHTON (Canterbury, 217 points)
He won three grand finals with Penrith - scoring vital tries in each of them - but it wasn't until he arrived at Canterbury last season that people started to realise what a great player Stephen Crichton really is. An explosive attacking threat, he is also arguably the best defensive centre in the competition. But perhaps most importantly of all, his leadership gave the Bulldogs a whole new dimension last season, when they reached the finals for the first time in eight years. Watching his former teammates celebrate a fourth straight premiership will presumably only harden his resolve to bring the trophy back to Belmore.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
9. PAYNE HAAS (Brisbane, 219 points)
If he's not the most damaging prime mover in the NRL, he is surely in the grand final. The Broncos have had some truly great props over the years, in particular Glenn Lazarus, Shane Webcke and Petero Civoniceva. Haas compares favourably with any of them, and he is still only 25, which is when the big men up front traditionally start to come of age. Injuries restricted the NSW and Kangaroos bulldozer to only 14 games last season, which perhaps explains Brisbane's dramatic fall from grace. If he's back to full capacity, you can expect Payne to inflict plenty of suffering on his opponents in 2025.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
8. TOM TRBOJEVIC (Manly, 233 points)
Which storyline will it be for "Tommy Turbo" this year? The champion in rude health, back to his brilliant best and lifting Manly into premiership contention? Or the forlorn hero limping from one physio appointment to the next? There is no more influential player in the NRL than Trbojevic at his best. The form he showed in 2021 - when he scored 28 tries in 18 games to win the Dally M medal - was simply mind-boggling, and if he can return to that phenomenal level, anything appears possible for the Sea Eagles. With a good squad around him, this shapes as potentially Turbo's best shot at a title. If, that is, he can stay on the park.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
7. MITCHELL MOSES (Parramatta, 233 points)
Despite spending the majority of his career in the shadow of the omnipotent Nathan Cleary, Moses finished last season as the incumbent NSW and Kangaroos halfback - helping both teams win the silverware they were chasing. Does he retain those jobs if Cleary is fit and available for selection? Probably not, but at least Moses has proven himself at representative level. Indeed, there is even a case to say he could play alongside Cleary in the halves in rep teams. Faces a new challenge in 2025, leading a rebuilding Parramatta outfit after the departure of former skipper Clint Gutherson. Moses shapes as the linchpin for the Eels as they launch a new era under rookie coach Jason Ryles.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
6. ISAAH YEO (Penrith, 257 points)
What a year 2024 was for Penrith's ultra-reliable co-captain. The towering lock not only helped lead the Panthers to a fourth straight premiership, he starred in NSW's Origin series win and then skippered the Kangaroos to victory in the Pacific Championships. A workhorse with a rare ability to distribute the ball as first receiver, Yeo's greatest asset is his consistency. He rarely makes a mistake, let alone hands in a sub-par game. The Panthers have built a dynasty around him. It might continue for a while yet, too.
- by Robert Dillon
Dylan Edwards Getty
5. DYLAN EDWARDS (Penrith, 262 points)
In an era of outstanding fullbacks, Dylan Edwards has entrenched himself as the gun No.1. Or should that be the No.1 gun? Whatever your preference, there is no denying the sheer class of the Penrith custodian, who has been a cornerstone of four consecutive premiership conquests. He also helped NSW win a State of Origin series last year at his first attempt, then starred for Australia in their Pacific Championships victory. Perhaps the best gauge of the elite level Edwards has reached is that the long-serving incumbent he replaced in the NSW and Australian teams, James Tedesco, had an outstanding 2024 season in his own right.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
4. KALYN PONGA (Newcastle, 274 points)
Is there a more watchable player in the NRL? Newcastle's talisman boasts a unique skill set and can unlock any defence with pace, footwork and sublime ball-playing nous. That's been enough to earn him a huge bank balance and social-media following, but clearly the 26-year-old is far from satisfied. As he enters his eighth season with Newcastle, the 2023 Dally M medallist still boasts only a single win in finals football. There is no such thing as a one-man team, but most would agree Ponga is the key if the Knights are any hope of challenging for a title. If he is fit and firing in the finals, Newcastle shape as a wildcard who will worry any opponent.
- by Robert Dillon
Jahrome Hughes Getty
3. JAHROME HUGHES (Melbourne, 278 points)
Came of age last season and was rewarded with the Dally M gold medal. The New Zealand Test half has been a quality player for years and is finally getting the credit he deserves. Along with Cameron Munster, Harry Grant and Ryan Papenhuzen, Hughes completes arguably the best spine in the business. Their presence ensures that Melbourne, minor premiers and runners-up last year, kick off 2025 as title favourites. If Hughes can reproduce last year's heroics, the Storm will be there or thereabouts when the whips are cracking.
- by Robert Dillon
Harry Grant Getty
2. HARRY GRANT (Melbourne, 293 points)
Inheriting the No.9 Storm jersey from Cameron Smith is surely the rugby league equivalent of batting after Bradman. It says plenty about Harry Grant that he has not only succeeded Smith as Melbourne's dummy-half, but also in the Queensland and Australian Test teams. The 26-year-old has an amazing ability to sneak over for a try, and most weeks he chimes in with 40 or 50 tackles. Promoted to Storm skipper last season, he led them to a grand final defeat and you can guarantee he will be hell-bent on going one better this year. He'll be hoping to become the first Storm skipper to hold the premiership trophy aloft since Smith in 2020.
- by Robert Dillon
Getty
1. NATHAN CLEARY (Penrith, 354 points)
It's not even really up for debate these days. After calling the shots in four consecutive grand final triumphs, Penrith maestro Nathan Cleary is widely acknowledged as the premier player in rugby league. Daylight second. The only question appears to be if he has reached his peak. At just 26, he could conceivably continue to become even better, although that would involve improving upon perfection. The champion half faces new challenges this season after undergoing a shoulder reconstruction and the departure of his long-time partner Jarome Luai, but he still has enough quality around him to ensure the Panthers are again among the short-priced favourites for a fifth title. Only the brave (or foolhardy) would back against a player seemingly destined to join the game's Immortals.
- by Robert Dillon
