Could Josh end up with… Cassidy?

The kissing challenge raised hormone levels and presented a few surprises… namely that Josh was a damn hot kisser.

“Shocked the sh*t out of me!” admitted Cassidy. In return, Josh described her as a very passionate kisser too. “#letsspendanightinthehideaway!” Josh said after the smooch, adding that he would score her a 9/10 for her abilities.

Cassidy added that the flirtation began even before they locked lips, when Josh threw her a flirty wink. “I was like, who are you? Where is this confidence coming from?”

Erin remarked that she had always known about that side of Josh. “You girls just haven’t seen it.”

Cassidy considered the kiss in her mind. “He’s sort of been, not even friend zoned, but brother zoned. But I was just like…”