Scott morrison aukus scott has always had a reputation for telling lies turnbull piles on pm criticism 20211103 p5ybp8.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 4 years ago

'I will treat all former Prime Ministers with respect': Morrison sidesteps Turnbull claims of a history of lying

Jorge Branco and 9News Staff

Powered by

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has said he will "treat all former Prime Ministers with respect" following an extraordinary broadside from predecessor Malcolm Turnbull in which he was called a liar.

The PM is currently in Dubai en-route to Australia after attending the COP26 summit in Glasgow where the French delegation claimed Mr Morrison lied to them about Australia's plans to scrap a $90 billion submarine deal.

When asked about Mr Turnbull's comment, Mr Morrison refused to be drawn into a tit-for-tat commentary.

Advertisement

"Australia made the decision not to go ahead with the contract for submarine that was not going to do the job that Australia needed to do, and I'll never make any apologies for that decision," Mr Morrison said.

"As you know, I always treat all former Prime Ministers with respect, and I'm going to continue to do that."

READ MORE: Four-year-old Cleo Smith found alive after vanishing three weeks ago

Former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull has called his successor Scott Morrison a liar, echoing comments by French President Emmanuel Macron. BBC - AAP

The retort comes after Mr Turnbull said the Prime Minister had a personal history of lying.

"Oh, he's lied to me on many occasions," Mr Turnbull said when asked about the spat between Mr Morrison and French President Emmanuel Macron.

"I mean there's quite a few examples in my book, but he's — Scott has always had a reputation for telling lies."

Mr Turnbull, who was replaced by Mr Morrison as leader of the Liberal party and Prime Minister in 2018 after an acrimonious leadership battle, said disingenuous behaviour would always reflect badly on a leader.

Advertisement

READ MORE: Eleven winners of Oz Lotto's $50 million jackpot

Mr Morrison refused to be drawn into commentary on Mr Turnbull's comments during his press conference in Dubai. Supplied

"But when you do that, as the leader of the nation, internationally, it reflects on us all," he said.

"Now look, deceiving people is bad wherever you do it, but when you do it at an international level, it has much graver ramifications."

Advertisement
Advertisement

Mr Morrison was due to speak this morning after Australia signed up to a 100-nation agreement to end deforestation by 2030, but instead changed plans and opted to start the journey home.

The spat over the cancellation of a $90 billion deal to buy diesel submarines from France's Naval Group in favour of nuclear-powered vessels made available through a new alliance with the US and the UK has boiled continuously on the sidelines of world leader meetings in Europe this week.

Asked by journalists on Monday whether he thought Mr Morrison lied to him about the deal, Mr Macron said: "I don't think, I know".

READ MORE: NSW drops travel barrier between Sydney and regions for the vaccinated

Advertisement

The Australian Government scrapped the $90 billion Future Submarines project with French company Naval Group, sparking a diplomatic row.. (Naval Group) Naval Group

Mr Morrison denied having lied and labelled the French President's criticism "slurs" and "sledging", in a detailed rebuttal on Tuesday accompanied by a message leaked to media purporting to show Mr Macron knew the deal was at risk before he was told.

"Should I expect good or bad news for our joint submarines ambitions?" Mr Macron reportedly asked, two days before the AUKUS coalition was set to be announced as Mr Morrison was trying to set up a call.

US President Joe Biden has admitted the handling of the landmark agreement that will allow Australia to buy nuclear-powered submarines using US and UK technology was "clumsy".

Advertisement
Advertisement

But Mr Morrison has insisted the dumping was essential for Australia's national security and bound to upset the French no matter how it was handled.

US President Joe Biden, left, with French President Emmanuel Macron, admitted that his administration was "clumsy" in its handling of the deal that deprived France of billions in defence contracts.. CNN

Mr Morrison insisted he made Mr Macron aware aware Australia was considering alternatives to the French deal when they had dinner in the Élysée Palace after the G7 meeting in June.

He said a "full-court press" from the French defence system in the immediate aftermath was proof of that but a joint French-Australian statement in late August — a little more than two weeks before the AUKUS announcement — "underlined the importance of the Future Submarine program".

Advertisement

Mr Morrison said approaching the US about using their nuclear-powered submarines was "always an option" but defended the initial French deal.

email icon

Contact us

Share a tip-off, video or photo with us

Most viewed in Australia

More to explore