Coronavirus australia nsw would be in lockdown under victoria roadmap scott morrison 20200907 p5xy2m.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 6 years ago

NSW would be in lockdown now under Victoria's roadmap, says Prime Minister

Mark Saunokonoko and Natalie Oliveri

Powered by

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has taken a swipe at Victoria's newly announced roadmap out of coronavirus restrictions, holding New South Wales up as the "gold standard".

He noted that, under Victoria's roadmap, parts of NSW would be under lockdown right now.

Speaking today about the rollout of COVID-19 vaccine, set for early next year pending successful trials, Mr Morrison criticised Victoria's plan.

Advertisement

LIVE UPDATES: AUSTRALIANS TO GET FREE VIRUS VACCINE IN EARLY 2021

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has criticised Victoria's roadmap out of coronavirus lockdowns. David Gray / Getty

He said the roadmap was "crushing news" for many and he hoped it was a worst-case scenario.

"We're yet still to receive the detailed modelling," Mr Morrison said about Victoria's data.

But, he said, he would not muscle in to alter Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews' plan, however added discussions would occur between Canberra and Melbourne.

"We do not have that authority to step in and tell the Victorian government they have to follow another plan. That is not how Australia's federation works," Mr Morrison said.

Mr Morrison alluded to Victoria needing to make its case for further federal financial support.

Earlier, Mr Andrews said his professional relationship with the prime minister should not be affected by the extension of Victoria's lockdown restrictions.

Advertisement

However, the premier said he did not expect him to be "pleased" about the challenging circumstances the state faces.

"He's got a job to do and that's not to be a cheerleader for the government. It's to be a passionate advocate on behalf of his members and that's exactly what he does," Mr Andrews said.

"That's why we have a very good relationship and one that I don't think will be in any way impacted by commentary made by him and others yesterday. We will continue to work respectfully in a partnership to get the best outcome we can."

READ MORE: Melbourne's roadmap out of lockdown questions answered

Advertisement
Advertisement

The prime minister also hinted at building "an integrated tracing capability" right across the country, to counter outbreaks.

He praised NSW as "the gold standard" that other states and territories had to follow and live up to.

But Mr Andrews said comparisons between NSW and Victoria were "unfair".

"I've seen this comparison quite a bit," Mr Andrews said today.

Advertisement
Daniel Andrews on September 7

Daniel Andrews has rejected comparisons with the COVID-19 situation in NSW. Nine

"And that's fair. People can draw the comparison. But it's unfair not to, I think, acknowledge the fact that they haven't had the community transmission that we've had.

"That's not a point of pride. It's just a fact. And trying to compare the two is not the same.

"I've seen all this commentary about, 'Oh, well, under our settings, they'd be in lockdown'. No, they wouldn't.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"Because they've not had the community transmission we've had. So we are different."

Mr Morrison said he wanted to see detailed plans of how Victoria's government plan to mitigate the economic consequences of its roadmap.

He also stressed that Sydney would be in curfew now if it was going on the same plan as Victoria.

The Prime Minister raised two questions that he believes are pertinent.

Advertisement

Police are seen along Elizabeth Street on September 06, 2020 in Melbourne, Australia.  Getty

"I think one of the questions that has been raised in relation to the Victorian plan is what assumption is being made about the efficacy of contact-tracing with the measures they've set out," Mr Morrison said.

"To what extent would those restrictions be otherwise lessened if a higher capacity and functionality of contact tracing were present."

The contact tracing of Victoria is coming under pressure.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"It's just not about how many people you've got on the phone," Mr Morrison said.

"Information systems are critical to this. The way work is structured and organised is critical to this. And it's an integrated tracing capability."

So what is the key to NSW's contact tracing?

In NSW, its special emergency operations centre is an integrated operation which involves the health department and is actually led by the police.

Advertisement

"Health central to its operations," Mr Morrison said.

"But there are many parts of government, when you're dealing with a crisis of this nature, which needs to be brought together."

Professor Brendan Murphy also hailed the NSW track and trace operation.

"They've had embedded public health units in all their local health districts. They've had very good outbreak response teams. They've got a large group of people," Professor Murphy said.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"It's not just about tracing. It's about the outbreak response. It's about the epidemiologist expertise. It's about that clinical leadership."

Mr Morrison has issued a warning to those Australian states and territories which have zero or low numbers of coronavirus.

He has asked them to ensure their teams are "match fit" while sitting on the sidelines.

email icon

Contact us

Share a tip-off, video or photo with us

Most viewed in Australia

More to explore