World cup news 2023 morgan turinui justin harrison on owen farrell tackle decision 20230821 p5j6ov.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Watch Live
Premier League on StanrightArrow
This was published 3 years ago

EXCLUSIVE: Rugby legends dumbfounded by Owen Farrell's escape from 'cut-and-dry' ban

Simon Cambers

Powered by

Two Wallabies greats have been left bemused by a judiciary panel's decision to let Owen Farrell get away with a \.

The England captain's well-document tackle on Wales replacement flanks Taine Basham wound up with Farrell escaping sanction.

That's despite Farrell's initial yellow card being upgraded to red in the eight-minute review window by match review officials.

Advertisement

READ MORE: World Cup hero had no idea of tragedy after thrilling win

READ MORE: 'Awkward question' after $800k NRL star becomes 'big flop'

READ MORE: England star's admission after 'gutting' loss

The decision not to sanction the veteran fly-half received widespread criticism. 

Such was the response that World Rugby confirmed its intention to appeal the call, which was made by an all-Australian panel.

Owen Farrell receives a yellow card from referee Nika Amashukeli after a high tackle on Taine Basham of Wales.

Owen Farrell receives a yellow card from referee Nika Amashukeli after a high tackle on Taine Basham of Wales. David Rogers via Getty Images

Speaking on the latest Rugby Heaven episode just hours before the response from World Rugby, two Wallabies greats expressed their sheer disbelief in the decision.

"I would have thought it was a cut-and-dry six weeks," said former Wallabies vice-captain Morgan Turinui. 

Advertisement

Watch the 2023 Rugby World Cup and Summer Nations Series on the home of rugby, Stan Sport. All matches streaming ad free, live and on demand

"I didn't see enough of a dip to make it a legal-level tackle. I didn't see enough change of direction from what the judiciary panel has said. 

"There's not enough, and he's coming up and out, not enough dip."

(Right to left) Owen Farrell, the England captain, sits in the sin bin with teammates Ellis Genge and Freddie Steward after they all received yellow cards at Twickenham.

(Right to left) Owen Farrell, the England captain, sits in the sin bin with teammates Ellis Genge and Freddie Steward after they all received yellow cards at Twickenham. David Rogers via Getty Images

Advertisement
Advertisement

The call comes at a time where there is intense scrutiny around rugby and its treatment of head injuries. 

More than 200 players have brought a lawsuit against the rugby unions of England and Wales as well as World Rugby.

There have been noticeable improvements in treatment of players who suffer head injuries, but instances like Farrell's seemingly fly in the face of that progress.

"It's very difficult to stand in front of a group of international quality players, professional athletes and coaches, and say 'We have a sanctioned pathway designed to change player behaviour and change coaches as well, we want to influence the result of the game, therefore red, yellow, all that sort of stuff' and then they do that," said Justin Harrison.

Advertisement

"A player with track record, a player with well-documented history of executing poorly under pressure. Not enough mitigation, to your point, to justify walking right back from, a red, a lock red, that was analysed in the bunker system over there that they've got that we had in Super Rugby. As analysed by experts and judged to be a red card. To walk back from that, I tell you what, the (KC) that was employed by Owen Farrell, I reckon Donald Trump is on the phone to him. He's that good."

Farrell's great escape came with social media commentary surrounding former All Blacks centre George Moala's tip tackle on a Canadian player, prompting suggestions of hypocrisy.

Moala was initially given a 10-match suspension, which was downgraded to five.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Turinui explained that Moala's tackle warranted a greater suspension than Farrell given there was no advantage for Moala whereas it stood to reason that Farrell would have benefited.

"What the world of rugby did well was sanction the tip tackle out of the game. Do you know why they could sanction it out? Because there's no tactical advantage in tip tackles," he said.

"I'll tell you what there is a tactical advantage in, tackling high on the ball and having seconds on the ball to slow defences. 

Advertisement

"Until the way the game is refereed and has laws around it, which takes away the tactical advantage of tackling high, they're not going to be able to sanction their way out of it. 

"This is the issue we get to."

World Rugby is expected to convene this week to discuss the Farrell incident.

Advertisement
Advertisement

England has one more warm-up contest against Fiji on August 27 before their Rugby World Cup campaign begins.

Most viewed in Rugby

More to explore