'They've overcompensated': Trent Robinson's plea to NRL as controversial rule 'goes too far'

The controversial disruptor rule has reared its head again after a try to Robert Toia was ruled out during the Roosters and Sharks clash in Perth.

Late in the second half, a kick was dropped by Sam Stonestreet after a contest with Toia. It looked like the Sharks' lead had been trimmed to 16-10 before the Bunker intervened and ruled it no try.

The Bunker's reasoning was that Toia had made contact with Stonestreet before the ball came down. Boos sounded out across Optus Stadium while Roosters brains trust Trent Robinson and Michael Cheika looked on in shock.

Watch the 2026 NRL season live and free on Nine and 9Now

Captain James Tedesco disputed the call, explaining how the process had been slowed down to the millisecond.

"A fingertip touch, and still debatable if the ball was in a catching position," Greg Alexander said on Fox League.

The decision created a major swing with the Sharks scoring through Tom Hazelton two sets later.

READ MORE: World No.1 rips reporter's 'terrible' question

READ MORE: Broncos giant granted leave to chase NFL dream

READ MORE: Arsenal cop 'big punch to the face' in title race

The disruptor call didn't cost the Roosters victory though, with the final score 34-22. In the aftermath, Alexander revisited the disruptor call and referenced the Gehamat Shibasaki decision from Friday night.

"We saw some outrageous things with the disruptor last night and we've just seen another one," he said.

Robinson believes that the NRL's interpretation of the rule has "gone too far."

"Choosing my words carefully on that," Robinson said.

"The direction that they (were) heading was right. There was too much disturbing of fullbacks, there's people that weren't competing, (but) that's gone too far.

"That was a clear example of two guys in a contest. Both guys looking at the ball. I mean, that's overcompensation. If someone tries to defend that, then we're heading in the wrong direction. I think that's the most extreme.

"I know there was a bit last night in the Brisbane game, but I don't think anybody can argue that, that was a disrupter.

"That wasn't the point of the rule. They've overcompensated. Hopefully there's a clear statement within a couple of days saying that we went to far, we need to get it right.

"I think everyone will go, yeah cool, I can understand that."

At half-time, Roosters premiership-winner Cooper Cronk was critical of the Bunker.

"I didn't like this call at all. I understand there's a lot of conjecture around the disruptor call, I understand when someone physically knocks the catcher out and doesn't have eyes for the football but this is the NRL. This is the best rugby league players on the planet and we're rewarding mediocrity when someone puts a fingertip (on a catcher).

"Rob Toia barely touches Stonestreet there and we're saying that disrupts an elite player catching the ball. It's part of an outside back's job to catch. I don't like that one ... that is not a disruptor." - with Sam Worthington