The ashes third test 2025 alex carey not out review david saker reaction england australia 20251217 p5nok7.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 10 months ago

Match referee takes action and reinstates review after snicko operator admits fault behind Alex Carey DRS howler

Lachlan Harper
Lachlan Harper

Updated . First published at

Powered by

ADELAIDE: Match referee Jeff Crowe has reinstated England's review after a howler from the decision review system allowed Alex Carey to reach his hundred on day one.

On Wednesday evening after day one of the third Test, snicko operator BBG Sports took the blame for the DRS decision.

After play, Carey admitted there was likely a "feather" on a shot he was given not out for, with England confirming it may take things further.

Advertisement

LIVE UPDATES: Australia vs England third Test, day two

THE MOLE: Cobbo 'looks a million bucks' amid Dolphins positional switch

READ MORE: 'You won't survive': Zerafa tees off on Tszyu after reboot fight

With the score 6-245, Carey was on 72 when he played and missed at a Josh Tongue delivery.

England appealed triumphantly but it was given not out with a review following.

Carey looked sheepish after the review as Adam Gilchrist noted on Fox Cricket: "It's almost like he's saying yes."

Alex Carey's Snicko decision.  Fox Cricket

Bizarrely, Snicko showed a considerable spike before the ball reached the bat but nothing when it was closer.

Advertisement

"That creaky handle," Alyssa Healy said on Fox Cricket.

However, BBG Sports was at fault, blaming an operation error.

Founder and head of technology, Warren Brennan, said in a statement that his company took "full responsibility".

On day two, Cricket Australia chief executive officer Todd Greenberg expressed his dismay at the process.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"It's certainly caused me some heartburn ... because the whole idea of technology is taking away the howler," he said on SEN.

Greenberg said the element of two human errors is "not good enough" with CA asking for answers from the technology provider.

The CA boss said the organisation is "not happy with it and we've don't think it's good enough".

Snicko is used over ultra edge by broadcasters in Australia. Hot spot has not been used for years.

Advertisement

In his post-match press conference, Carey was asked directly if he hit it.

"I thought there was a bit of a feather or some sort of noise when it passed the bat," he replied.

"It looked a bit funny on the replay with the noise coming early. If I was given out I think I would've reviewed it, probably not confidently, though. It was a nice sound as it passed the bat."

Advertisement
Advertisement

Carey admitted he did have a bit of luck with the decision review system before being asked if he's a walker.

"Clearly not," he replied quickly.

BBG Sports' statement took into account Carey's comments.

Advertisement

"Given that Alex Carey admitted he had hit the ball in question, the only conclusion that can be drawn from this, is that the 'Snicko' operator at the time must have selected the incorrect stump mic for audio processing," Brennan said.

"In light of this, BBG Sports takes full responsibility for the error."

It's understood that the stump microphone was operating from the bowler's end when the spike appeared.

Alex Carey's sheepish look.  Fox Cricket

Advertisement
Advertisement

England's bowling coach David Saker appeared after Carey and was less jovial about it.

"The boys are pretty confident he hit it," he said.

"I think the calibration of the Snicko was out quite a bit and it's probably been the case for the series. There's been some things that don't really measure up. At the stage, it was a pretty important decision.

"Those things hurt, you get through it, but you'd think in this day and age the technology is good enough to pick things up like that."

Advertisement

After a number of contentious decisions, Saker said he didn't believe questions had been asked by officials but flagged it could be an avenue in the future.

"After today, maybe that might go a bit further," he said.

"There's been concerns about it for the whole series and we shouldn't be talking about that after a day's play. It should just be better than that. It is what it is."

The decision proved vital with Carey going on to score 106.

Most viewed in Cricket

More to explore