Off-grid Aussie mum wins court bid to start bringing kids home from foster care

An Australian woman and her British partner whose three children were put in foster care due to their off-grid lifestyle can start bringing them home for visits, an overseas court has ruled.

Catherine Birmingham and Nathan Trevallion were stripped of parental care last November due to the conditions at their remote farmhouse in Abruzzo, Italy.

Italian authorities took issue with almost every aspect of their lifestyle, including inadequate sanitation, a lack of steady household income, and social isolation.

The family had no running water or electricity, and the children did not attend a proper school.

The children were removed after a court suspended the couple’s parental responsibility and have been living in foster care ever since.

Speaking to 60 Minutes earlier this year, Birmingham, a former horse trainer turned life coach, described the toll the separation was taking on their children.

Read more

How an unconventional Australian family became caught in a media storm in Italy

“The scribbling on the walls... they’ve gone mad. The nightmares that my son wakes up with in horrific screams of terror: ‘Mummy, help me. I’m scared’,” she said.

The Juvenile Court of L’Aquila has approved a staged reunification process that will allow the family to spend increasing amounts of time together at home.

The children – a nine-year-old girl and twin seven-year-old boys – can immediately return to the family home for daytime visits.

From October, they will also be allowed to stay overnight on weekends.

“The ruling partially revises previous court decisions and sets out a gradual reunification process, allowing the children to return home for daytime visits immediately and, from October, for weekend overnight stays with their family,” lawyer Simone Pillon said.

Social services will oversee the process and assess how the children reintegrate before the court considers any permanent return home.

Birmingham and Trevallion are not satisfied with the pace of the process, with Pillon saying the family plans to appeal to pursue complete reunification.

Birmingham told 60 Minutes she refuses to abandon her parenting style to appease authorities.

"We did say yes to a lot of things, but we were not going to do things that were going to damage our children," she said, referring to recommendations from the court, such as sending them to school and improving the living quarters.

"Why should we have to compromise to make other people feel comfortable?"

Their case first came to the attention of authorities after all five family members were taken to hospital with mushroom poisoning.

Authorities then looked into the family’s living arrangements at their small, remote farmhouse, where Birmingham and Trevallion had chosen to raise their children off the grid, away from many aspects of modern life.

A court ruling issued in November found the family had no significant social interactions or stable income and lacked adequate sanitary facilities.

Read more

Swans player remains stood down despite being cleared by police

The court suspended the couple’s parental responsibility on November 20 and placed the children in foster care.

Birmingham was initially allowed to stay at the facility with her children but was ordered to leave in March under another court ruling based on recommendations from social services.

The family’s plight has garnered widespread attention worldwide, with Birmingham saying she turned to the media out of desperation.

“This is why I wanted to make sure that the world is watching our kids because if anything happens, I want them to know who our children are,” she said.

The case has fuelled debate about alternative lifestyles, parental rights and the extent to which authorities should be able to intervene in family life.

The couple can now welcome their children home for visits, though the battle for permanent, full custody is far from over.

- Reported with Reuters