Key points of Xie murder case
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE ROBERT XIE MURDER TRIAL:
WHAT THE CROWN SAID:
* One person murdered the Lin family at their North Epping home in Sydney, in the early hours of July 18, 2009
* Xie sedated his wife before leaving their bed and creeping into the Lin residence, 300 metres away
* Xie knew the location of the Lin's outside power box to enable the electricity to be turned off
* Xie had access to a key and knew the layout of the Lin house
* Bloodied shoe prints in the Lin home were consistent with Asics sneakers Xie wore
* On May 6, 2010, Xie cuts up shoe boxes, showing "consciousness of guilt"
* Small "bloodstain" - dubbed Stain 91 - on Xie's garage floor "most likely" contains DNA of four Lin family victims
* Partly motivated by his perceived "inferior" status in the Lin family - supported by evidence of Witness A, an inmate who recorded Xie speaking disparagingly of Min Lin
WHAT THE DEFENCE SAID:
* It wasn't one person in the dark
* Improbable all five victims could be controlled by one person; crime scene suggests more than one assailant
* Xie's wife Kathy Lin confirms his alibi of being asleep with her at the time of the murders
* Disputes DNA evidence and the Crown's assertion stain on Xie's garage floor is blood
* No evidence showing Xie motivated to harm the Lin family
* Xie got on well with Lin family and was particularly close to nephew Henry
* He cut up the shoe boxes as he feared police would falsely implicate him in the murders
* Conversations with Witness A were "nothing more than jail talk"
* Denies Crown's suggestion of a sexual motive, details of which cannot be published.
Share a tip-off, video or photo with us
Most viewed in NSW
Boxing coach’s shooting death not linked to gang feud, but police probe bikie links
Alan Jones accuser ‘revolted’ at alleged groping, Peter FitzSimons tells trial
Worker fighting for life after being crushed by ride-on roller on major Sydney road
Accounting boss among five charged over alleged ‘ghost car’ fraud