News 2023 netball australia launch investigation after collingwood magpies melbourne vixens umpiring error 20230327 p5j47s.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • All sports
  • Cricket
  • AFL
  • NRL
  • Rugby
  • Football
  • Golf
  • Motorsport
  • Netballtick
  • Tennis
  • netball
    GIANTS NetballGN37
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT70
  • netball
    Melbourne MavericksMM63
    Sunshine Coast LightningSCL53
  • netball
    Queensland FirebirdsQF51
    West Coast FeverWCF69
  • netball
    Melbourne VixensMV67
    NSW SwiftsNS57
  • netball
    Sunshine Coast LightningSCL74
    GIANTS NetballGN54
  • netball
    West Coast FeverWCF57
    Melbourne MavericksMM60
  • netball
    NSW SwiftsNS68
    Queensland FirebirdsQF62
  • netball
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT61
    Melbourne VixensMV42
  • netball
    NSW SwiftsNS60
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT66
  • netball
    Queensland FirebirdsQF66
    Sunshine Coast LightningSCL59
  • netball
    Melbourne VixensMV50
    Melbourne MavericksMM59
  • netball
    GIANTS NetballGN60
    West Coast FeverWCF61
  • netball
    Sunshine Coast LightningSCL49
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT67
  • netball
    Melbourne MavericksMM60
    Queensland FirebirdsQF57
  • netball
    Melbourne VixensMV55
    West Coast FeverWCF64
  • netball
    GIANTS NetballGN66
    NSW SwiftsNS65
  • netball
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT58
    Melbourne VixensMV44
  • netball
    West Coast FeverWCF56
    Melbourne MavericksMM52
  • netball
    Melbourne VixensMV62
    West Coast FeverWCF51
  • netball
    Adelaide ThunderbirdsAT61
    Melbourne VixensMV40
Watch Live
Premier League on StanrightArrow
This was published 3 years ago

'We've just been completely robbed': Netball Australia launches investigation into 'absolute fiasco'

Emily Patterson
Emily Patterson

Powered by

Netball Australia has launched a second investigation in as many days after the Melbourne derby between the Collingwood Magpies and the Melbourne Vixens ended in controversy following an umpiring mistake.

The error saw the Vixens given two consecutive centre passes with the game hanging in the balance with three minutes left to play.

The Vixens went on to clinch the match by a goal, 62-61.

Advertisement

READ MORE: Aussie injured in 'horrendous' finish line crash

READ MORE: Records tumble in 'crazy' T20 run chase

READ MORE: Rory McIlroy stunned in remarkable 24-year first

Under the rules of netball, the centre pass alternates between the two teams, regardless of who scores the preceding goal.

Shimona Nelson of the Magpies calls out.

Shimona Nelson of the Magpies calls out. Kelly Defina via Getty Images

Which team takes the first centre pass is decided by the team captains at the toss.

"Netball Australia is reviewing the circumstances that led to an error in the fourth quarter of yesterday's match between the Collingwood Magpies and the Melbourne Vixens, where the Vixens were awarded two consecutive centre passes," Suncorp Super Netball said in a statement on Monday.

"Under the Suncorp Super Netball Rules of the Game, the result of the match stands with the Melbourne Vixens winning 62-61."

Advertisement

After trailing for most of the match, the Vixens scored off both centres to draw level in the fourth quarter before shooting two more goals - including a clutch Mwai Kumwenda two-point bomb after the siren - to clinch the win.

Upon realising the Vixens had been given the advantage of two centre passes, Collingwood goal attack Sophie Garbin informed coach Nicole Richardson of the error.

Richardson then tried to advise the umpires but later said she was "basically ignored".

Magpies coach Nicole Richardson attempts to appeal a decision regarding the order of centre passes in the final minutes of the round two Super Netball match between Collingwood Magpies and Melbourne Vixens.

Magpies coach Nicole Richardson attempts to appeal a decision regarding the order of centre passes in the final minutes of the round two Super Netball match between Collingwood Magpies and Melbourne Vixens. Kelly Defina via Getty Images

Advertisement
Advertisement

Following a lengthy discussion with the technical officials post-match, the result was upheld.

Speaking to the media afterwards, Richardson did not mince her words when voicing her fury at how the situation played out.

"What happened in the last minute and a half is an absolute fiasco," she said.

"You cannot have a result like that. This is an elite level of competition

Advertisement

"You've got an automated scoreboard that tells you whose centre pass it is. You've got a bench that knows exactly whose centre pass it is, but the bench does not have the power to do anything about it? That has just cost us the game. That's why I'm angry.

"[The umpires] just wanted to finish the game and we wanted to bring it to their attention then and there in the moment of the game and they didn't want to listen to us and the game continued.

"We've just been completely robbed because we would've had an opportunity to go two goals up. We would have had an opportunity to starve them of the ball and take some time off the clock, and they shot after the siren anyway.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"That is a massive error. They've stuffed up, they've cost us a game."

The loss caused the Pies to drop to fourth on the ladder and draw level with its cross-town rivals with four points a piece.

"This competition is so tight, anywhere from one to eight can win this, and wins early are really important," Richardson said.

The latest inquiry will occur in addition to the probe into the drawn match between the Adelaide Thunderbirds and the NSW Swifts on Saturday night because of a power outage at Netball SA Stadium.

Advertisement

The backstories and controversies that have ignited feuds involving athletes

Kane Cornes has unleashed an extraordinary spray on Nick Kyrgios, labelling him "the greatest waste of talent we've ever seen".

The backstories and controversies that have ignited feuds involving athletes

Most viewed in Netball

More to explore