Eddie mcguire collingwood presidency exit tony jones comment 20210210 p5iqy2.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Watch Live
Premier League on StanrightArrow
This was published 5 years ago

Tony Jones: Eddie McGuire's polarising Collingwood reign did far more good than bad

Tony Jones
Tony Jones

Powered by

I recall a story Eddie McGuire told me probably midway through his 23-year reign as Collingwood president.

He was walking down a street with his two then-young sons when a group of youngsters, onboard a passing tram, began hurling abuse at him.

It was all Collingwood related but at that moment, he wondered if the presidency was worth being belittled in front of his boys.

Advertisement

History will show the club won out and his sons would go on to accept that their dad would, at times, cop flak.

And copped flak he has. Some justified, some not.

Eddie McGuire resigns as Collingwood president after a report into 'systematic racism' at the club. The Age

He's not naive enough to suggest he doesn't bring some of it upon himself; a sometimes blinkered view of the game he loves so much polarising public opinion.

Indeed, public opinion of McGuire is split in the wake of his resignation as Collingwood president.

In truth, he was always going to struggle not to step down following the leaking of the independent report that found Collingwood guilty of systemic racism.

The report included a veiled reference to Eddie's apparent failings as an influential, if not THE influential, figure at the club.

The situation was not helped by his now infamous, and now lethal, comment that it was a \.

Advertisement

McGuire went off script, prompting his detractors to go off tap.

Eddie McGuire walks past premiership cups with his family, on their way to confirm his exit from Collingwood. Getty

His opponents would've been high-fiving last night, celebrating the downfall of football's highest-profile administrator.

But outweighing that will be those equally furious that McGuire has, quite possibly, become a victim of those who thrive on being outraged.

Advertisement
Advertisement

But even his most ardent detractors would have to concede that McGuire has done more for his club than any other president in the game's history.

Not just club, but community.

The Magpies enjoy one of the most envied headquarters in Australian sport, right in the heart of the sporting precinct.

It also has a premiership cup in the trophy cabinet, won on McGuire's watch.

Advertisement

Brick and mortar and silverware are very much part of his legacy, but so too are the many projects to help those in dire need of support.

The homeless were found homes ... the hungry were given food ... the lonely were taken in as part of the Collingwood family.

These weren't photo opportunities for McGuire. Most of the work was done with not a camera in sight.

So, as much as history will record his exit as a result of a racism issue that should've been dealt with much, much earlier, McGuire will also be remembered as a visionary.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Eddie McGuire

Eddie McGuire reigned over Collingwood for 23 years. Getty

Many leaders are denied the dignity of exiting on their own terms and McGuire has clearly joined the list.

He'll be hurting.

There's no doubt about that.

Advertisement

Nor should there be any doubt that when it's weighed up, his achievements will far outweigh his failings.

Most viewed in AFL

More to explore