Sydney australia evander tuala inquest brawl 20250825 p5zgf2.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 1 year ago

Inquiry begins into mystery over apprentice's death in fatal street brawl in Sydney

Alex Mitchell

Powered by

The family of a young man punched to death in the middle of Sydney remain searching for answers as an inquest into the violent incident begins.

Evander Tuala, 23, died from brain injuries sustained in a brawl on Oxford St, in Sydney's CBD, in 2022, after being knocked unconscious, and falling and hitting his head on the footpath.

The inquest into the incident began in Lidcombe, in Sydney's west, today to examine who was responsible for Tuala's death.

Advertisement

READ MORE: Seven of every ten teachers find workload unmanageable, claims study

Evander Tuala, 23, from Western Sydney, was hit on Oxford Street in Darlinghurst last night during a clash of two groups.

Evander Tuala died in 2022 after being hit and falling during a brawl in Sydney. Nine

Despite five people having been convicted over the affray that surrounded the death, no one has been charged with the killing.

Two groups of men became engaged in a fight at the Oxford Hotel on April 9, 2022, before they left the venue about 12.30am.

But a second altercation between the groups in nearby Taylor Square minutes later proved fatal for Tuala, who can be seen on video footage collapsing after being struck.

It is unclear who struck the 23-year-old and that will be a central focus of the inquest, the court was told.

A CT scan shortly after Tuala arrived at St Vincent's Hospital showed a number of fractures along a brain haemorrhage.

He underwent surgery that same day but was later declared brain dead, with his life support turned off on April 11.

Advertisement

READ MORE: More than half of employers found to have been approached by staff asserting right to disconnect

SMH Generic Photo shows, The NSW new Coroners Court at Lidcombe, Sydney. Forensic Medicine Police investigations deaths in custody tragedies police shooting deaths . Photo by, Peter Rae Tuesday 6 August, 2019

The inquest is taking place at the NSW Coroners Court in Lidcombe in Sydney's west. Peter Rae

Counsel assisting Chris McGorey noted the hearing was a "fact-finding exercise" rather than one that would end with criminal liability being asserted.

But he did note the inquest can make a referral to the director of public prosecution.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"He is a dearly loved young man who was in the prime of his life with a significant amount of promise," he said.

"His loss is a matter of significant concern for the community."

About a dozen members of Tuala's family were in court on today, with some sobbing their way through a re-telling of his death.

One of the men who has been charged with the affray - Keidan Donovan-Phillips - was legally represented at the inquiry and sat in the courtroom.

Advertisement

The court was told police believe Donovan-Phillips was standing close to Tuala when he was struck but NSW Deputy State Coroner Carmel Forbes will need to rule on his involvement in the death.

DOWNLOAD THE 9NEWS APP: Stay across all the latest in breaking news, sport, politics and the weather via our news app and get notifications sent straight to your smartphone. Available on the Apple App Store and Google Play.

email icon

Contact us

Share a tip-off, video or photo with us

Most viewed in Australia

More to explore