Questions raised over police evidence in convicted murderer scott austics appeal 20190722 p5x7a6.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 7 years ago

Police evidence questioned in convicted murderer’s sentence appeal

Louise Rennie
Louise Rennie

Powered by

The actions of WA Police investigators have come into question, as a convicted murderer's historic appeal began in the state's highest court.

Scott Austic is serving a life sentence for the 2007 murder of his 35-year-old pregnant lover Stacey Thorne, who was stabbed 21 times in her Boddington home, south-east of Perth.

The former mechanic has always maintained his innocence.

Advertisement
Scott Austic is serving a life sentence for the 2007 murder of his 35-year-old pregnant lover Stacey Thorne, who was stabbed 21 times in her Boddington home, south-east of Perth.

Scott Austic is serving a life sentence for the 2007 murder of his 35-year-old pregnant lover Stacey Thorne, who was stabbed 21 times in her Boddington home, south-east of Perth.  9News

A packet of Winfield Blue cigarettes, allegedly stained with the victim's blood, which was photographed at Mr Austic's house.

A packet of Winfield Blue cigarettes, allegedly stained with the victim's blood, which was photographed at Mr Austic's house. 9News

His lawyers are fighting to have the conviction thrown out, claiming key pieces of evidence may have been planted.

Among them, a packet of Winfield Blue cigarettes, allegedly stained with the victim's blood, which was photographed at Mr Austic's house.

Nowhere to be seen in the initial forensic search, it suddenly appeared in photos taken by police 30 hours later. Police now claim it was "innocently" placed on the table for the purpose of taking a photo. Questions have also been raised about the alleged murder weapon, found by police in a paddock days after SES volunteers scoured the area.

Lawyers argue the weapon would have been discovered in the initial search, if it were there.

The court is also expected to hear from forensic experts, who say the bloodied knife could not have caused the wounds on Ms Thorne's body.

The court is also expected to hear from forensic experts, who say the bloodied knife could not have caused the wounds on Ms Thorne's body.  9News

The packet of cigarettes was nowhere to be seen in the initial forensic search, but suddenly appeared in photos taken by police 30 hours later.

The packet of cigarettes was nowhere to be seen in the initial forensic search, but suddenly appeared in photos taken by police 30 hours later.  9News

Advertisement

The court is also expected to hear from forensic experts, who say the bloodied knife could not have caused the wounds on Ms Thorne's body.

After exhausting all his appeals, Mr Austic was granted a rare second chance to clear his name by the WA Attorney-General, due to concerns about some evidence.

His mother Robyn Austic said she hopes to finally have her son home.

"I believed him from day one," she said.

Advertisement
Advertisement

The hearing has been set down for seven days.

email icon

Contact us

Share a tip-off, video or photo with us

Most viewed in Australia

More to explore