Sydney brothers accused of fleecing vulnerable senior 20230829 p5rfjj.html – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
This was published 3 years ago

Brothers accused of fleecing vulnerable senior of $349k

Dimity Clancey
Dimity Clancey

Powered by
A Current Affair

When we grow old, we hope our loved ones will be there to protect us.

But when that can't happen, isolated and vulnerable people are often left exposed to predators.

Barbara is 89, she's frail and lives in a retirement village in Sydney's eastern suburbs.

Advertisement
When we grow old, we hope our loved ones will be there to protect us.

When we grow old, we hope our loved ones will be there to protect us. A Current Affair

READ MORE: Highway cop hits back after being charged for clocking 207km/h to help colleague

When approached by A Current Affair, it was clear Barbara suffered some cognitive impairment and wasn't in a state to be interviewed.

But what police allege happened to Barbara is too serious to ignore.

Eric and Mark Shumsky are brothers, both aged in their 60s.

Eric Shumsky.

Eric Shumsky. A Current Affair

READ MORE: Disgraced plumber faces court over neighbourhood sewage clash

It's alleged Eric was Barbara's neighbour at the retirement village and is a budding thespian who loves Shakespeare.

Advertisement

Mark is a solicitor with broad experience across a number of areas of law.

Detectives set up a strike force to investigate after they received a tip-off from Barbara's bank.

An abundance of old money is contributing to an elder abuse epidemic.

An abundance of old money is contributing to an elder abuse epidemic. A Current Affair

READ MORE: Child protection cop shares warning all parents need to hear

Advertisement
Advertisement

Between the brothers, police allege they defrauded the elderly woman of $349,000.

Officers claim between 2019 and 2022, Eric helped Barbara transfer $316,000 to him to pay for his personal debts and living expenses.

Eric was remanded in custody after he and his brother were arrested and charged last month.

Mark was granted bail and was ordered to report to police three times a week.

Advertisement
A Current Affair reporter Dimity Clancey and Mark Shumsky.

A Current Affair reporter Dimity Clancey and Mark Shumsky. A Current Affair

READ MORE: Fed-up residents call out council over sinking homes

Both brothers have been charged with dishonestly obtaining financial advantage by deception - Eric with one count, Mark with four - and both will face court next month.

When tracked down by A Current Affair, Mark was inside his law firm on Sydney's North Shore, where he's still practising.

Advertisement
Advertisement

His employer, Stacks Collins Thompson, part of Stacks Law group, said in a statement that Mark reported his charges to them and the law society and that the practice will comply with all professional conduct obligations.

Solicitor Christine Smyth specialises in succession law.

Solicitor Christine Smyth specialises in succession law. A Current Affair

The firm also said Barbara was never a client.

Eric is yet to enter a plea but Mark's employer said he will fight the charges and Stacks Collins Thompson will represent him in court.

Advertisement

Solicitor Christine Smyth specialises in succession law and said the allegations shine a light on a bigger issue - that an abundance of old money is contributing to an elder abuse epidemic.

"A large amount of wealth is concentrated in a proportion of people, namely baby boomers and older generations, and they hold the largest amount of wealth in this country," Smyth said.

One in 15 Australians over the age of 65 and one in four people over the age of 85 have some sort of cognitive impairment.

One in 15 Australians over the age of 65 and one in four people over the age of 85 have some sort of cognitive impairment. A Current Affair

One in 15 Australians over the age of 65 and one in four people over the age of 85 have some sort of cognitive impairment.

Advertisement
Advertisement

"They fail to appreciate what the red flags are because they're lonely, their memory might be failing, their confidence might be failing," Smyth said.

"They say it takes a village to raise a child but it also takes a village to protect our vulnerable."

And who knows, one day we all might need our village.

"If we all have the good fortune to age, then we are all at risk of this happening to each and every one of us and that is why as a community we need to be taking a greater stance and stepping up and protecting our aged," Smyth said.

Most viewed in A Current Affair

More to explore